An Introduction to the Types of Transcription and How to Choose

Published on 25 October 2023 at 09:09

Transcription refers to the process of converting spoken words or audio into written text. It has a wide range of applications, such as creating subtitles for videos, documenting interviews and meetings, producing transcripts for legal or medical purposes, and much more. Transcription is extensively used in various fields, including journalism, education, law, medicine, business, and entertainment. It plays a pivotal role in enhancing accessibility, accuracy, and efficiency in communication and information sharing.

It's important to note that there are different types or styles of transcription. The type of transcription best suited for a project depends on the purpose and quality of the source material, as well as the client's requirements. In this post, we'll explain the three main types of transcription: edited, verbatim, and intelligent, and help you choose the best type for your specific needs.

 

The Main Types of Transcription


1.) Edited transcription


Edited transcription focuses on delivering a clear, concise, easy-to-read, and understandable document. Edited transcription involves omitting or correcting some parts of the original content deemed unnecessary, irrelevant, redundant, or grammatically incorrect. For example, filler words (such as "um," "uh," and "like"), false starts, repetitions, stutters, slang, and colloquialisms may be removed or replaced with more formal language. Edited transcription may also rephrase or restructure some sentences to improve clarity and coherence.


Edited transcription is suitable for clients who want a polished and professional document that captures the main ideas and messages of the original content. Edited transcription is often used for academic research, business reports, presentations, speeches, podcasts, and interviews.

Example:

  • Original content: "So yeah, I mean, I think that's basically it for today's meeting. Um...any questions or comments from anyone? No? Okay then...uh...thanks for your time and attention guys. See you next week."
  • Edited transcription: "That concludes today's meeting. Any questions or comments? None? Thank you for your time and attention. See you next week."

 

2.) Verbatim Transcription


Verbatim transcription is a type of transcription that captures every word and sound of the original content exactly as they are spoken or written. Verbatim transcription does not omit or correct anything from the original content, even if they are grammatical errors, filler words, false starts, repetitions, stutters, slang, or colloquialisms. Verbatim transcription may also include non-verbal cues and sounds, such as pauses, laughter, coughing, sighing, etc.

Verbatim transcription suits clients who want a detailed and accurate document reflecting the original content's tone and context. Verbatim transcription is often used for legal proceedings, medical records, psychological studies, media analysis, and qualitative research.

Example:

  • Original content: "So yeah, I mean, I think that's basically it for today's meeting. Um...any questions or comments from anyone? No? Okay then...uh...thanks for your time and attention guys. See you next week.
  • "Verbatim transcription: "So yeah (pause) I mean (pause) I think that's basically it for today's meeting (pause) Um (pause) any questions or comments from anyone? (pause) No? (pause) Okay then (pause) uh (pause) thanks for your time and attention guys (pause). See you next week (laughter)."

 

3.) Intelligent Transcription


Intelligent transcription is a type of transcription that captures the meaning and essence of the original content without including unnecessary or irrelevant details. Intelligent transcription involves omitting parts of the original content deemed insignificant or distracting from the main points and messages. For example, filler words (such as "um," "uh," and "like"), false starts, repetitions, stutters, slang, and colloquialisms may be removed. However, intelligent transcription does not correct grammatical errors or rephrase sentences as long as they do not affect the meaning or clarity of the content.

Intelligent transcription may also include some non-verbal cues and sounds, such as pauses, laughter, coughing, sighing, etc., if relevant to the context or convey some emotion or attitude.

Intelligent transcription is suitable for clients who want a concise and clear document that preserves the meaning and intent of the original content. Intelligent transcription is often used for transcripts, subtitles, captions, and summaries.

Example:

  • Original content: "So yeah, I mean, I think that's basically it for today's meeting. Um... any questions or comments from anyone? No? Okay then... uh... thanks for your time and attention guys. See you next week."
  • Intelligent transcription: "That's it for today's meeting. Any questions? No? Thanks for your time and attention. See you next week."

 

How to Choose a Transcription Type


The choice of a transcription type depends on several factors, such as:

  • The purpose and audience of the transcription: What is the goal of the transcription? Who will read or use it? How will it be presented or distributed?
  • The quality and format of the source material: How clear and audible is the speech? How many speakers are there? How fast or slow do they speak? How formal or informal is their language? How structured or spontaneous is their conversation?
  • The budget and time constraints of the project: How much money and time are available for the transcription? How much human intervention or editing is required? How much automation or software assistance is possible?

Based on these factors, you can choose a transcription type that best suits your needs. For example:

  • If you need high-quality and accurate transcription for legal or academic purposes, choose verbatim transcription. However, this type of transcription may be more expensive and time-consuming than other types.
  • Choose edited transcription if you need a clear and concise transcription for business or media purposes. However, this type of transcription may require some human intervention or editing to ensure consistency and correctness.
  • Consider choosing intelligent transcription if you need a brief and coherent transcription for marketing or entertainment purposes. However, this type of transcription may lose some details or nuances of the speech that may be important for some audiences.

 

In Conclusion


Transcription is a useful and versatile tool that helps convert speech into text. You should select a transcription type that best meets your needs based on your goals and preferences. Hopefully, this post helped in understanding the primary types of transcription and how to choose the appropriate one.


written by Anne Albright

Add comment

Comments

There are no comments yet.